Getty ImagesWhen Jack Posobiec walked into the Department of Justice in Washington, DC last February, he thought he would finally get some answers about Jeffrey Epstein.
But when he and other MAGA supporters were given essentially just rehashed, already-public material – and when the government put a damper on the release of any new information this July – they balked.
“We were all told more was coming. That answers were out there and would be provided. Incredible how utterly mismanaged this Epstein mess has been. And it didn’t have to be,” Posobiec posted on social media on 7 July.
Now, Donald Trump is finding it hard to shake loose the conspiracy theories that have animated his base since he first broke through into Republican politics a decade ago.
Getty ImagesPosobiec, who emerged from the fringes of the internet in 2016 when he spread false rumours about a child abuse ring based in a Washington DC restaurant – a conspiracy theory that became known as Pizzagate – is just one of many MAGA die-hards who believes officials are hiding key truths about Epstein’s life and death.
The disgraced financier and convicted sex offender died by suicide in a New York prison cell in 2019 while he was awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges.
On a recent podcast hosted by Breitbart News editor Alex Marlow, Posobiec said the MAGA base see this case as shorthand for the thorough rot of the so-called “deep state”.
“It’s not that they care about Epstein personally,” he said. “It’s that they care that there’s this optic that Epstein was somehow involved with a shadowy system that actually has control over our government, control over our institutions, control of our lives, and really is a ruling power over us.”
Over the years, some have claimed that government officials possess files on Epstein that reveal sordid details, including that a “client list” exists with notable names on it who may have participated in some Epstein’s alleged crimes.
Trump has, in the past, played to that crowd. During last year’s election campaign, he said he would have “no problem” releasing Epstein case files, and after the election directly answered a question about whether he would “declassify” the files by saying: “Yeah, yeah, I would.”
Conspiratorial thinking has been a part of President Trump’s movement from the outset. His entry into the once-crowded world of Republican Party politics a decade ago came as he amplified the false theory that Barack Obama wasn’t born in the United States.
Now, however, the world of conspiracy is biting back.
Epstein’s crimes are real and horrific, and there remains the possibility that further information could emerge about them.
But they have also become subsumed by grander narratives – Pizzagate, and later QAnon, the sprawling interactive conspiracy theory that swamped the internet during Trump’s first term, pushing the idea that the highest echelons of society were controlled by a child-abusing elite cabal. The conspiracy theory spread through cryptic messages posted by a pseudonymous character called Q.
Mike Rothschild, author of several books on Trump-era conspiracies, including The Storm Is Upon Us: How QAnon Became a Movement, Cult and Conspiracy of Everything, said Epstein was mentioned in several such messages dating back to late 2017.
“Epstein is seen as one of the major players in a global ‘paedo elite’ that’s been trafficking children for centuries, and that Q and Trump were supposed to put an end to once and for all,” he told the BBC.
But after the justice department meeting in February, administration officials, including FBI director Kash Patel and his deputy Dan Bongino – who both stoked Epstein rumours for years – started to dampen talk of any major revelations.
Then, on 8 July, the Department of Justice and FBI said in a memo that Epstein’s cause of death was suicide and there was no evidence he had a “client list”.
The president seemed eager to move on, calling the Epstein case “sordid, but it’s boring” while also blaming Democrats for continuing to make it an issue.
Many Trump supporters are happy to follow the president’s lead. But a subset of extremely online MAGA supporters are still deeply passionate about the Epstein case.
Several MAGA voices, including former Fox News host Tucker Carlson, have alleged that Epstein was employed by the Israeli security services. And among more extreme elements of the movement, the conspiracy theories around Epstein sometimes veer into the antisemitic.
But Rothschild said most of the people in MAGA world are simply itching for more information – if it indeed exists – about the financier’s connections with Bill Clinton and other Democrats and Trump opponents. Epstein cultivated powerful people from both major US political parties.
The long history of MAGA’s Epstein obsession mean Trump is now finding it difficult to satisfy the conspiratorial elements in his base.
The story took another twist late on Thursday as The Wall Street Journal reported Trump had sent Epstein a “bawdy” birthday greeting in 2003. The pair’s one-time friendship is well-known, but Trump says he cut ties with Epstein long ago and filed a lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal’s parent company, its owner and two reporters following the report.
Meanwhile, Trump seemed more willing to indulge the conspiracy theorists, posting on Truth Social: “Based on the ridiculous amount of publicity given to Jeffrey Epstein, I have asked Attorney General Pam Bondi to produce any and all pertinent Grand Jury testimony, subject to Court approval.”
There is no doubt that conspiracy theories clearly have the power to motivate some of the president’s base. QAnon supporters were among some of the most visible participants at the January 2021 riot at the US Capitol.
In a survey conducted just before last November’s election, the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) think tank found that nearly a fifth of Americans agree with QAnon-linked statements, including most pointedly: “The government, media, and financial worlds in the US are controlled by a group of Satan-worshipping paedophiles who run a global child sex trafficking operation.”
Many see the Epstein case as a confirmation of those views, and the QAnon-believing population is heavily pro-Trump, the PRRI found, with 80% backing the president.
And with that support has come influence. Posobiec, the Pizzagate and Epstein conspiracy theorist who was at the DOJ meeting in February, reportedly accompanied Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth on a recent trip to Europe.
He also has been photographed meeting with neo-Nazi’s, although he denies being a white nationalist himself.
He did not respond to the BBC’s request for comment.
He is adamant that Epstein’s case is connected to the wider conspiracy world.
“It ties to Covid, it ties to lockdowns, it ties to vaccines,” Posobiec said, on the Alex Marlow podcast, which was recorded at a conference last week where multiple speakers brought up Epstein and demanded further revelations.
“It ties to so many different buckets of the anger people are feeling.”
Rich Logis, a former longtime Trump supporter who broke ranks and started an organisation called Leaving MAGA, said that these outlandish theories serve “as ties that bind many within the MAGA community”, even amongst those who doubt them.
Logis says Trump’s dismissal this week of their concerns this left some supporters “feeling confused and stunned”.
“They expected Trump to keep his promise and reveal those who allegedly aided and abetted Epstein,” he said.
If the Epstein case presents a political quagmire for Trump, there is also a problem for his supporters, particularly the vocal influencer class, in figuring out where to funnel their rage. Targeting the president could backfire when it comes to their own followers.
“Many of the major influencers are furious,” Rothschild said, “and while they might not take it out on Trump, they might take it out on the GOP (Republican Party) in general.”
Trump has so far stood by Pam Bondi, his attorney general. But she, Patel and Bongino may increasingly feel the pressure if MAGA’s conspiracy wing continues to demand more files – whether or not they actually exist.
